Beer Can Chicken: Mouthwatering or Myth?

Beer Can Chicken: Mouthwatering or Myth?

“Make sure you try the happy pizza.”

That was the only piece of advice given to us by a friend before our trip to Siem Reap last year. Seeing how my eyes lit up like JLaw in Hawaii, she knew that no further elaboration, nor travel tips, were needed. Oh yeah, you might wanna check out this really old building they got called Angkor Wat too.

I felt a similar twinge of excitement when I first heard about this phenomenon called beer can chicken. Cooked upright with an open can of beer shoved up its rear, the beer allegedly evaporates into the chicken during the cooking process, giving you one of the juiciest, most flavorful birds you’ve ever tasted.

Hopping online to learn more about this beer butt bird, Ren and I found several reputable articles debunking the method, calling it not just a myth, but a waste of good beer. Through much experimentation, the data for which you can read about HERE, they concluded that apart from getting the skin crackly and evenly browned, having a Bud up the pope’s nose is NOT the best way of roasting a chicken. In fact, it does many things wrong and can even be considered dangerous. To summarize their findings, they determined that very little evaporation of beer actually occurs (less than 1%), as evidenced by the immeasurable difference in the can’s weight before and after cooking. This means that virtually all of the beer remains in the can and makes no contact with the bird whatsoever. What little vapor that does escape is so miniscule, that it’s hardly enough to add any kind of discernible moisture or flavor to the chicken.

On top of that, and this was something that we noticed firsthand, the can essentially acts like a plug, preventing heat from entering and cooking the bird from within. We wound up with a chicken that was beautifully crisped on the outside, but with distressingly undercooked meat, despite being in the oven for over an hour. We had to throw it in the microwave a couple of times during dinner to get rid of the pinkness and small amounts of blood still oozing from its joints. Not cool.

Still, the bird, as you can see in these pictures, looked pretty damn awesome, so I can understand why people do it in spite of the beer not having any proven benefits. It’s fun. One of my favorite bloggers – Ben from You Fed a Baby Chili? – even holds annual beer can chicken contests complete with trophy, the results and pictures from which you can view HERE. He’s a scientist on top of being a food blogger, so I’m pretty sure that he’s well aware of the method’s, how do I put it, imbeerfections? 😉

Check out those delicious spice rub flecks on the chicken’s back side. Ren got the recipe from Bon Appetit magazine (posted below). It’s an easy-to-remember, 4-3-2-1 recipe of kosher salt, light brown sugar, sweet paprika (Ren used pimenton), and cayenne pepper.
Beer Can Chicken

Chicken doing yoga. Beer can chicken may be a myth, but Cambodian happy pizza, I assure you, is not. :)
Beer Can Chicken

Can you tell what kind of beer beer that is? I’ll give you a clue: Whapak!
Beer Can Chicken


  • 1 (2 to 3-pound) whole chicken
  • 2 cloves garlic, smashed
  • 1 (12-ounce) can beer


  • 4 Tbsps kosher salt
  • 3 Tbsps light brown sugar
  • 2 Tbsps sweet paprika (Ren used pimenton)
  • 1 Tbsp cayenne pepper


  1. Preheat oven to 450 degrees F. Wash chicken with cold water, then pat dry with paper towels.
  2. Mix spice rub ingredients in small bowl. Rub 1/2 of ingredients on inside cavity of chicken. Gently peel skin away from chicken, then rub mixture into meat under skin.
  3. Open can of beer and pour out around 1/2 cup. Drop cloves of garlic into beer can. Place chicken, with open end down, over beer can, inserting can into cavity. Place upright chicken in large saute pan.
  4. Place chicken in oven for 10 minutes, then lower temperature to 325 degrees F and cook for another hour, or until internal temperature in thickest part of thigh reaches 165 degrees F on meat thermometer. Serve with roasted vegetables.
There are 10 comments for this article
  1. Jeanette at 2:17 pm

    I pretty well always do a whole chicken this way. I do not use beer. Instead, I just use half a can of water.

    The can of water gets as hot as the oven and while not much water might evaporate, the can of water itself is hot enough to cook the chicken from the inside as well.

    I always add a bit of oil to my spice rub, mix it up, and then rub it all over the chicken.

    I convection roast the chicken at 275F for an hour or so. Then I turn the heat to 325F and finish roasting the chicken. That takes another half an hour or so, until the juices run clear and the legs move easily.

    I save all the drippings and bones and make broth…so tasty. .

  2. JB Macatulad at 10:15 pm

    Hi Jeanette, many thanks for stopping by and sharing your experience. It’s good to hear that the method works for you. When we tried it, the skin was beautiful but the meat was slightly undercooked. Oh well. Maybe we’ll try it again, but with a vertical roaster next time since the upright method does seem to culminate in gorgeous, crisp skin. :)

  3. rissa at 11:09 pm

    your chicken looks gorgeous! and the veggies too! i tried this twice, the chicken was moist but the beer taste was barely there. removing the chicken from the beer can was such a challenge since both were very hot. oh and i used red horse too! :)

  4. JB Macatulad at 7:38 am

    Thanks Rissa! Yeah, it was kinda tricky removing the can. Ren had to hold the chicken while I twisted the can out. All this hot liquid just gushed out onto my hands haha! We couldn’t detect the taste of beer either, but the skin was nice and crisp and evenly browned. :)

  5. Jeanette at 10:05 am

    If you are having trouble removing the beer can, simply coat it with non-stick cooking spray prior to putting the chicken on it.

  6. Aleksandra at 3:39 am

    I am not sure if mentioned method is a myth but for sure your chicken looks stunning!

  7. JB Macatulad at 8:18 am

    Thanks Aleksandra! Opinion appears to indeed be split regarding this beer can method. I have found many people online who swear by it, and just as many who aren’t as convinced. With taste being so subjective, I guess it all boils down to what works for you. There really isn’t a one, universally correct method, so to each his/her own right? :) Thanks for stopping by!

  8. Meridien at 5:48 am

    Hi! I wonder, does the heating can inside the chicken “off-gas” paint VOCs (volatile organic compounds)? Sounds like a picky technical question, but getting rid of VOCs in paint and new carpet has been a desirable development, by getting rid of nasty toxic odors. I think there’s been a similar concern about nonstick cookware at higher temperatures, too. Just a thought…thanks!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv badge